I have a question regarding rails lengths. Do 16' rails provide anything other than less rails vs a 8' rail? Looking at the drawings I can start with a 3.5' rail at the bottom and with the bracket spacing be OK with the 8' rails. Should this be signed off by an engineer?
I think you’ll find it easier to cut and pull rails out than installing new. Only replacing rails? Hmm.
RE The “drawings” for the job. What does the rail schedule show? 3’-5” starter, but then what?
I’d imagine with a DW and its limited load capacities, 8 footers would be fine as long as you don’t end up with a fish plate right at the bracket, but what does the plan call for? Are 8lb rails on the schedule, or 15lb?
If the drawing you have is the “approved plan”, you’re kind of stuck with what it calls out for unless reviewed and re approved.
But here are a couple of my thoughts.;
How many stops and what’s the rise? Not knowing the structure you’re going to be tackling (oil platform?), is there a chance of going through the DW roof if it’s accessible? Or cutting approx 13’ high through a side wall to create an entrance point for the 16’s or 8’s? (And to remove the old rails).
Kind of tough to survey the job, being 180 miles out to the (proposed) Gulf of America.
I think you’ll find it easier to cut and pull rails out than installing new. Only replacing rails? Hmm.
RE The “drawings” for the job. What does the rail schedule show? 3’-5” starter, but then what?
I’d imagine with a DW and its limited load capacities, 8 footers would be fine as long as you don’t end up with a fish plate right at the bracket, but what does the plan call for? Are 8lb rails on the schedule, or 15lb?
If the drawing you have is the “approved plan”, you’re kind of stuck with what it calls out for unless reviewed and re approved.
But here are a couple of my thoughts.;
How many stops and what’s the rise? Not knowing the structure you’re going to be tackling (oil platform?), is there a chance of going through the DW roof if it’s accessible? Or cutting approx 13’ high through a side wall to create an entrance point for the 16’s or 8’s? (And to remove the old rails).
Kind of tough to survey the job, being 180 miles out to the (proposed) Gulf of America.
The original approved drawings show brackets at 8', 23', and 37' 1/4". Hence my thought of starting with a 3.5' rail, and missing the brackets with the fish plates.
Pulling the old rails is a non-issue, as we will would cut them to whatever they need.
2 stops around 27' of travel. This customer tends to overthink as it is in the oil/gas industry. There are gouges in the rails, from the slackrope safety engaging, which they want replaced. My original proposal to them was to simply repair the gouges, as that is a standard repair anywhere in the world. They wanted 2 proposals one for repair and 1 for replacement.
I talked them into the standard rail file repair.